SAP vs Oracle: A Comparative Analysis of ERP Systems in 2024

Post Category :

Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) is like an all-in-one tool for businesses. It’s software that helps make everything run smoother. Big companies like SAP and Oracle offer ERP solutions that gather important information from different places, putting it all in one easy-to-use space. This kind of software is handy for handling things like keeping track of products, managing the supply chain, setting prices, and even taking care of HR tasks like driving and training employees.  

If you’ve been looking into ERP systems, you’ve probably heard about SAP and Oracle. They are like giants in the world of ERP software. But how do you choose between them when they seem so similar? We’ve looked into the details of each company to help you understand the differences. This way, you can determine which one might better fit your business. 

SAP vs Oracle: Differences for Informed Business Choices

ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) software is a constant presence for businesses throughout the history of commercial software. SAP and Oracle have invested heavily in ERP technology to effectively consolidate financial records for large enterprises.  

Distinguishing between SAP and Oracle ERP systems can be challenging for outsiders due to the seemingly uniform landscape of the ERP software market. Beyond streamlining internal business processes, both platforms integrate sales, manufacturing, and supply chain functions into financial accounting. Additionally, they offer centralised databases, serving like a single source of truth for the entire organisations. This centralised approach enhances the utilisation of business intelligence software, enabling companies to access financial data in one consolidated location for informed decision-making.  

While SAP and Oracle claim to cater to businesses of all sizes, the cost may challenge smaller or medium-sized companies. However, the investment in this software is justifiable for rapidly expanding enterprises with intricate operations involving procurement, supply chain, and multiple locations. 

Comparing the Companies: A Detailed Look at SAP & Oracle

Both SAP and Oracle’s ERP offerings prominently emphasise financial management. They feature accounting and reconciliation-based financial software, offering the advantage of streamlined recordkeeping, consolidation across various departments and locations, and seamless integration of sales and procurement throughout extensive supply chains.  

These platforms go beyond basic functionalities by supporting multiple currencies and languages, ensuring regulatory compliance with customisable settings and forms, and enabling real-time data management. To enhance financial analysis and boost revenue, both SAP and Oracle incorporate advanced computing capabilities like Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML) into their features. This infusion of AI and ML facilitates quicker and more insightful analysis of diverse financial records, contributing to more effective decision-making processes.

Feature
SAP Business One Professional
Oracle Fusion Cloud ERP
Accounting
Offers standard features such as accounts payable (A/P), accounts receivable (A/R), and fixed asset management
Provides standard and advanced features covering accounts payable to asset management retirement and amortization
Budgeting
Includes basic budgeting features for managing and executing general planning
Offers advanced tools, including asset lifecycle management, in addition to standard budgeting features
Pricing
Utilizes straightforward pricing tools to manage product pricing
Pricing tools are designed to match market conditions, currency, exchange rates, and calculate profit margins, rebates, and discounts
Human Resources (HR)
Features a well-designed employee portal, payroll, and e-recruiting functionality to support retention and manage employee turnover
Provides good reporting capabilities, including visual representations
CRM
Integrates marketing, sales, and finance to create a comprehensive view of customers for contextual sales
Offers good marketing support
AI and ML
Relies on the HANA computing platform as the basis for all SAP offerings, and includes an AI digital assistant "CoPilot" for data accessibility
Incorporates AI tools like Digital Assistant across all Oracle software components, using natural language for database sorting

Accounting

SAP and Oracle ERP systems offer comprehensive accounting features, including Accounts Payable (A/P), Accounts Receivable (A/R), and fixed asset management.  

Oracle ERP strongly emphasises enhancing financial management and reporting reliability, coupled with the integration of governance, risk management, and compliance (GRC) requirements. Oracle takes pride in its risk management solutions, designed to enforce enterprise-wide compliance and automate industry-specific compliance needs.  

On the other hand, SAP provides robust risk management tools that aid businesses in identifying and understanding risk factors, preventing cash leakage, and enforcing policies effectively.  

Oracle’s approach involves implementing tools based on common processes. For instance, the Asset Management to Retirement module covers the entire asset lifecycle, from acquisition to amortisation to disposal. Oracle also employs a point-of-sale (POS) approach in the “Transaction to Cash Position,” seamlessly integrating it with long-term financial information.

Budgeting

SAP’s software offers basic budgeting capabilities, focusing on general planning execution. In contrast, Oracle’s ERP system stands out with its significantly superior budgeting features. 

Oracle provides a dedicated tool named “Asset Lifecycle Management,” empowering businesses to leverage the financial potential of their equipment and facilities while efficiently addressing standard budgeting requirements.

Pricing

In the realm of pricing, Oracle surpasses SAP’s basic features. Oracle allows flexible adjustments to base prices based on market segment, currency, exchange rates, etc. It also manages profit margins, rebates, and discounts through well-defined guidelines. 

HR

SAP leads in HR management, offering comprehensive tools beyond Oracle’s capabilities. SAP covers various HR functions, consolidating critical information in one accessible location. In addition to payroll, SAP ERP software includes e-recruiting functionality, contributing to employee retention and reducing turnover.  

While Oracle’s reporting capabilities may not match SAP’s robustness, its emphasis on visual representations facilitates quick communication. This feature becomes especially valuable if you seek to base HR decisions on data visualisation, allowing you to comprehend your company’s historical and future trends swiftly. 

CRM

Regarding Customer Relationship Management (CRM), Oracle and SAP offer distinctive strengths. 

Oracle: 

  • Provides a unified platform for planning campaigns and budgets. 

SAP: 

  • Offers cross-functional processes integrating finance, procurement, and marketing.  
  • Boasts have comprehensive customer account management tools that cover various customer-related aspects.  
  • Facilitates effective lead generation by providing access to customer histories.  
  • Integrates seamlessly with marketing, sales, and finance, offering a holistic view of customer history and potential ongoing needs.  
  • Enables marketing in context and the implementation of smarter selling strategies through enhanced customer knowledge. 

Both solutions receive high marks for sales-order management. SAP caters to distributors of all sizes and across diverse industry segments. Oracle excels in reporting and data features, enhancing its overall CRM capabilities.

AI & ML:

In the landscape of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML), both SAP and Oracle incorporate these advanced technologies into their software, albeit with distinct approaches.  

SAP:  

  • Leverages the HANA computing platform introduced in 2008, driving automation, predictive analytics, and machine learning tools across SAP’s product range.  
  • Features an AI-driven digital assistant named “CoPilot,” enhancing accessibility to deep analytics and data without manually exploring old reports. 

Oracle: 

  • It utilises AI and ML within its software, with embedded AI driving tools like supply chain finance and accounts payable.  
  • Introduces the Digital Assistant AI to assist users in maximising platform benefits.  
  • Offers analytics and big data tools incorporating natural language processing for efficient database searching and analysis.  
  • Presents Oracle Database, providing benefits akin to SAP’s HANA regarding analytics and data processing.

Cost Comparison of SAP and Oracle:

Determining the exact cost of implementing SAP or Oracle is challenging as neither company publicly discloses pricing. Various factors influence the overall cost, including business size, scope, and the chosen pricing packages. 

SAP: 

  • No public pricing is available.  
  • Customised packages with full implementation and support can range from five to six figures.  
  • A one-user subscription to SAP’s cloud-based model typically costs between $100 and $150 monthly.  
  • For example, SAP’s Cloud Hosted Professional Plan by SEIDOR is listed at $132 per month, and the SAP Business One Perpetual License is $3,213 per user. 

Oracle: 

  • No public pricing is disclosed.  
  • Oracle’s Fusion Cloud Service is estimated to cost between $150 and $200 per user per month, based on the Global Price List released in December 2022. 

It’s important to note that these are general examples, and the actual cost will vary based on specific plans, configurations, and negotiations with the vendors. Customised full implementation and support packages may involve significant investments, while cloud-based models offer a more accessible monthly subscription cost.

Conclusion

Businesses must focus on their unique requirements in navigating the choice between SAP and Oracle for ERP systems. While Oracle stands out in financial reporting and budgeting, SAP takes the lead in comprehensive HR management. Given the undisclosed details, the decision hinges on understanding specific operational needs, aligning features with business goals, and carefully negotiating pricing. In the ever-evolving landscape of 2024, a thoughtful and tailored approach ensures optimal integration, setting the stage for sustained business success. 

Here’s where VE3 emerges as a strategic partner, offering expertise in ERP solutions and a deep understanding of both SAP and Oracle ecosystems. With a commitment to personalized consulting, we can guide businesses through the intricate process of selecting, implementing, and optimizing the chosen ERP system. Our tailored approach ensures that the selected solution aligns seamlessly with the unique operational requirements, maximizing efficiency and fostering long-term growth. By leveraging our comprehensive solutions, you can confidently navigate the complexities of ERP implementation, positioning themselves for success in the competitive landscape of 2024 and beyond. To know more, explore our innovative digital solutions or contact us directly.

EVER EVOLVING | GAME CHANGING | DRIVING GROWTH

VE3